A woman in a dark jacket walks away from the camera down a quiet street

Research

The Career Paradox for UK Women

In our 2014 survey of 1,000 UK professional women, 80% said their employer supported women, yet 36% had faced prejudice at work because of their gender. Here is what we found, sector by sector, and what it asks of employers.

said their employer was supportive of women
80%
had faced prejudice or discrimination at work because of their gender
36%

5 min readUpdated

Key takeaways

  • In Talking Talent’s 2014 survey of 1,000 UK professional women, 80% said their employer was supportive of women, yet 36% had experienced prejudice or discrimination at work because of their gender.
  • One in four women in the 2014 survey (25%) said their gender had held back their career, and 12% said they had been passed over for promotion because of it.
  • Every sector surveyed showed the paradox: at least seven in ten women felt supported in each, while 26% to 53% had faced gender prejudice.
  • Financial services showed the sharpest contradiction in 2014: 84% of women felt supported and 53% had faced prejudice.
  • Working mothers saw the same pattern: 71% said their employer supported working mothers, yet 37% said being a working mother had hindered their career.
  • Women aged 35 to 44 were the least likely to say their employer was good at progressing women: 63%, against 79% of 16 to 24 year olds.
  • Asked what would help, women put flexible working first (38%), then role models (32%) and free or subsidised childcare (31%).

What is the career paradox?

The career paradox is the gap between how supported women say they feel at work and what many of them have experienced. In 2014 we asked 1,000 UK professional women about their employers, their careers and the barriers they had met. Most were positive: 80% said their employer was supportive of women, and more than seven in ten rated their employer well for keeping and developing women.

The same women described a different day-to-day reality. 36% had experienced prejudice or discrimination at work because of their gender, and for a third of them it took the form of being overlooked for promotion. One in four (25%) said their gender had held back their career.

Both were true at once. That is what makes the paradox hard to see from inside an organisation: a positive score can sit on top of experiences that never reach it.

Which sectors showed the paradox most clearly?

Every sector we surveyed showed the pattern. In each, at least seven in ten women felt supported; between a quarter and just over half had faced gender prejudice.

Feeling supported, facing prejudice: women in ten UK sectors, 2014

In every sector, at least seven in ten women said their employer supported women. The share who had faced gender prejudice varied far more: from 26% in education to 53% in financial services.

SectorFeel supportedFaced gender prejudice
All women surveyed80%36%
Advertising, marketing & media83%51%
Law85%47%
Education82%26%

Source: Talking Talent, The Career Paradox for UK Women (full results, October 2014): survey of 1,000 UK professional women.Statements: “My employer is supportive of women” and “I have experienced prejudice or discrimination at work because of my gender”. Sector figures are read from the report’s chart and rounded; the report doesn’t give the number of women in each sector. Sorted by the share who faced prejudice.

Financial services showed the sharpest contradiction: 84% felt supported and 53% had faced prejudice. In law, 85% felt supported, yet only 32% said men and women were valued equally in mid-level roles, falling to 27% at board level.

Accountancy rated highest on more positive measures than any other sector, with 94% feeling supported, and still 43% of women accountants had faced prejudice. Women in engineering and manufacturing were the least likely to feel supported (74%) and the least positive about their employer’s ability to keep women.

Education had the lowest share facing prejudice (26%), which is why its dots sit furthest apart on the chart. A wide distance there is good news, not a bigger paradox.

What did working mothers experience?

The pattern repeated for working mothers. 71% said their employer supported working mothers, a third said their employer offered a career break to have a child, and 14% said it offered free or subsidised childcare. Yet 37% said being a working mother had hindered their career, and a third had experienced prejudice or discrimination because they were a mother. Of those, 37% had been passed over for promotion as a result.

Ratings dipped in the middle of a career. Women aged 35 to 44 were the least likely of any age group to say their employer was good at progressing women (63%, against 79% of those aged 16 to 24), and support for working mothers dipped at the same age (65%, against 78%). The report pointed to this stage, around parental leave, flexible working and the move into senior roles, as the point in the pipeline where support matters most. It is where parental leave and return-to-work coaching does its work.

“Just having someone to ask the right questions helped me to engage properly with the necessary issues… It’s given me a thought process and a structure – a framework that can be re-applied when I need it.”

A partner at a global law firm, on coaching around the return from parental leave, in the 2014 report.

Why do women say they feel supported when the reality is different?

From our coaching with professional women, we saw three reasons why positive answers and difficult experiences sat side by side:

  • It feels safer to talk about others. Women often acknowledged a problem through colleagues’ experiences rather than their own.
  • Speaking up can feel risky. Some worried how senior leaders would hear it, and what it might mean for their prospects.
  • Loyalty runs deep. Criticising the people you need on your side to progress, often a senior team of men, can feel like a career risk.

None of this is a failure of policy on paper. It is a gap in how consistently good policy is applied day to day, and in whether people feel safe to say when it isn’t.

What did women say would help?

Asked what would most help women progress, they put flexible working first (38%), then role models (32%), free or subsidised childcare (31%) and more thought given to provision for women and working mothers (31%). A quarter (25%) wanted a change in culture and attitudes, which takes time.

Two answers could make a difference sooner: better coaching or advice for women (21%) and coaching for their managers (14%). 7% wanted quotas for women in senior roles.

Does the career paradox still matter?

These findings are from 2014. The question they raise still applies to any organisation that relies on surveys: does a positive score show what people experience, or what they feel able to say?

Four places to start:

  • Look beyond the average. Break survey results down by gender, level, age and parental status, and set them beside promotion and retention data.
  • Make honesty safe. Confidential conversations and external coaching surface what a survey may not.
  • Support the transitions. Before, during and after parental leave, and the step into senior roles, through women’s leadership programmes and coaching for working parents and carers.
  • Equip managers to notice and act, so good policy shows up in everyday decisions. Inclusive leadership development is designed to build that habit.

What does it look like in practice?

For newer research on where careers stall, read Climbing Walls, Not Ladders.

About the research

Talking Talent surveyed 1,000 professional women working in the UK and published the full results, with figures for ten sectors, in October 2014. The report doesn’t state the fieldwork dates, the research agency or the number of women in each sector, so small differences between sectors may not be meaningful. Where the report’s text and its chart differ, we use the chart. All figures are rounded to whole numbers.

References

  1. Talking Talent, The Career Paradox for UK Women (full results, October 2014): survey of 1,000 UK professional women.

Questions about the career paradox for UK women

What is the career paradox for women at work?

It describes women who say their employer supports them while also experiencing prejudice, discrimination or blocked progression. In Talking Talent’s 2014 survey of 1,000 UK professional women, 80% said their employer was supportive of women, yet 36% had faced prejudice or discrimination at work because of their gender, and one in four said their gender had held back their career.

Which sectors were best and worst for women in the Career Paradox research?

In the 2014 survey, accountancy rated highest on more positive measures than any other sector: 94% of women accountants felt supported, though 43% had still faced prejudice. Law, education and accountancy rated best for working mothers. Advertising and media, and engineering, rated worst for both women and working mothers. Financial services had the highest share facing prejudice (53%).

Why do women say they feel supported when they have faced prejudice?

From Talking Talent’s coaching with professional women, three reasons stood out. It feels safer to describe a problem through colleagues’ experiences than your own. Raising it can feel risky for your prospects. And loyalty to the people you need on your side to progress can make criticism feel like a career risk. The result is positive survey answers that hide difficult experiences.

What support did women say would help their careers most?

In the 2014 Career Paradox survey, flexible working came first (38%), then role models (32%), free or subsidised childcare (31%) and more thought given to provision for women and working mothers (31%). A quarter wanted a change in culture and attitudes. Better coaching or advice for women (21%) and coaching for managers (14%) were seen as changes that could help sooner.

How old is the Career Paradox data?

The survey of 1,000 UK professional women was published by Talking Talent in 2014 (full results, October 2014). The report doesn’t state the fieldwork dates, the research agency or the number of women in each sector, so small differences between sectors may not be meaningful. The findings date from 2014 and are a prompt to look at your own data.

How can an employer tell whether it has a career paradox?

Compare what people say with what happens to them. Break engagement or inclusion survey results down by gender, level, age and parental status, and set them beside promotion and retention data for the same groups. Add confidential routes such as external coaching, where people can say what a survey doesn’t capture. A gap between positive scores and uneven progression is the paradox at work.

Talk to us about the paradox in your organisation

Tell us where progression stalls for women in your organisation. We’ll talk through where coaching could help, from parental leave to the step into senior roles.

Newsletter

The Talent Brief

An occasional email for HR and people leaders: what our coaches and leadership team are writing about, news of our work with clients, and events where you can hear from us.

We’ll send you The Talent Brief by email. You can unsubscribe at any time. See our privacy policy.